what we really came for was the Philly Cheesesteaks. legend has it that in the 1930's, two hotdog sellers had a brainwave and decided to serve up something different for lunch. one of them bought some thinly sliced steak from the market, and proceeded to chop up the beef and some onions for grilling. the sizzling product was served on hotdog buns. it was not until 20 something years later did they drizzle the steak sandwiches with cheese wiz. the Philly Cheesesteak was thus born.
although the sandwiches were good, they didn't give me the satisfaction i was looking for. well, i guess only burgers can satiate a burger fan's bovine desires. for the past semester, i'd been on the lookout for The Burger. that meant trawling food blogs, food forums and professional food critiques. i've sampled some of the more popular ones, like Burger Joint, Island Burger, and 5 Guys. in all honesty, they were good, but never great. however, i did have a near-great experience at Shake Shack, Madison Square Park during late fall.
the Shack Burger was simple - a thin patty cooked medium and accompanied by a slice of American cheese, fresh lettuce and two tomato slices, drizzled with the Shack sauce, all sandwiched between two lightly buttered and fried potato buns. it was moist, fresh, beefy, and bursting with flavor. oh yes, it was awesome. the chocolate milkshake was so rich it was like drinking ice cream - just the way i enjoy my shake.
the Double Stack had a lot of potential, but it crashed like the Dow because people got greedy. i thought the burger was trying to achieve too much. this was an enormous burger that will have many people finding trouble taking a full bite off it - which i think totally defeats the purpose. to me, a good burger should be sized for a mouthful just big enough to get a little of everything; this one was just a little too tall. because the 'Shroom was twice as thick as the beef - which to me should be the star of the show - it completely overwhelmed the poor dead animal. all i tasted was mushroom and cheese. not that it didn't taste good, but for me it took the meat out of the burger which lowers it to the rank of a sandwich, really. just like how some highly-acclaimed movies can leave you with a twang of disappointment because you expected much more, i suffered the same fate because Shake Shack did the unthinkable - my beef patty came well done.